Discussion about this post

User's avatar
LR's avatar

Just had a Genova and

Spectracell run under same

Conditions… a lot of contradictions of results.

Oddly

Pantotheanate score identical to your results.

Expand full comment
Jeff's avatar

I had blood drawn for three micronutrient tests from Spectracell, vibrant, and Cell Science Systems on the same day and time. Of the three, Vibrant had the most deficiencies and Cell Science had the least. No deficiencies in the Spectracell test but it had 4 markers with borderline score.

My markers with deficiencies/borderline are as follows:

Vibrant:

WBC: B5 & vitamin A were deficient

Serum: Vitamin C was deficient.

RBC: omega 3 index was 5.32 which they consider average. AA/EPA was 36.6 which is considered high. I will consider taking fish oil.

Serum: B12 and vitamin D , 25-OH were high. Vitamin D was also confirmed by Labcorp to be high.

My manganese serum and WBC zinc are right at the minimum reference values so I consider those a deficiency just like with Spectracell (as you’ll see below)

Serum Inositol, WBC inositol, and WBC carnitine were also at or barely above the minimum reference values so I consider those deficient.

Spectracell:

Chromium, Glucose-Insulin Interaction, Manganese, and Zinc were all borderline. Vitamin A is at 75 which is barely above borderline so I consider it borderline or deficient. Apparently I need a lot of preformed vitamin A because of a gene snp. B2, magnesium, selenium, carnitine, vitamin E are barely above the borderline so I consider those a deficiency.

Cell Science:

Asparagine, calcium, oleic acid (omega 9) were the only markers with borderline.

Magnesium was the only marker with a deficiency.

My diet at the time was about 25 - 35% lean animal protein, 45-60% carbs mostly from fruits, and 10-20% fat mostly from nuts and animal protein.

No supplements two days before the test.

My usual supplement stack consists of b vitamins, multivitamin, amino acids, minerals, vitamin D, and choline with inositol. I wasn’t taking any fish oil supplements prior.

Overall, each test has its advantages and disadvantages. I really like all including Genova NutrEval. However, if I could only afford one test I’ll probably go with Vibrant because they measure both short term and long term micronutrient reserves.

I hope that helps someone!

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts