Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JBR13's avatar

Masterjohn is a nutritional research machine - thank you for sharing the fruits of your labors!

Expand full comment
JBR13's avatar

I tried to find oxalate content of natto, but there were no studies or clear data on that particular soybean product. Using a bunch of soybean cultivar data and studies showing oxalate reduction via soaking, cooking, and fermentation of soybeans and other legumes with B. subtilis, I conservatively, and very roughly, estimated the following regarding total (insoluble + soluble) oxalate content in natto:

Soybeans, on average, have 3.5-5mg total oxalate per gram soybean

Oxalate content is cut by 50% after: soaking, discarding the soaked water, boiling for 2-3 hours, and discarding the boil water.

Oxalate content decreases by 8% (of original raw soybeans) per day of fermentation at 100-105 degrees F. 8% of 3.5-5mg is 0.28-0.4mg (per gram of soybean).

1 tablespoon of natto weighs about 15g, and contains roughly 154mcg K2.

Total oxalate content of 1 tablespoon of 24hr-ferment natto is roughly and conservatively 24-38mg. Total oxalate should reduce by 0.28-0.4mg for each additional 24hr of fermentation at 100-105 degrees F.

...

My more liberal estimate using one of the lowest-oxalate cultivars of soybean is 8mg total oxalate in 1 tablespoon of 24hr-ferment natto.

My most conservative estimate using the highest-oxalate cultivar of soybean is 45mg total oxalate in 1 tablespoon of 24hr-ferment natto.

Average of 8mg, 24mg, 38mg, and 45mg is about 29mg total oxalate in 1 tablespoon natto

...

I'm also emailing companies that make natto to see if they have their own lab data on oxalate content. Boiled lentils - according to Harvard's oxalate data - is low-oxalate. Could use a natto starter and do an experiment like this - https://www.reddit.com/r/fermentation/comments/ueqdde/great_success_with_brown_lentil_natto/

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts